top of page

Special Situations: The Price of Certainty

Writer: Grupo de Negócios da Escola Politécnica da USP
Grupo de Negócios da Escola Politécnica da USP
Oct 7, 2025
4 min read

The Certainty Effect, in a nutshell: the search for liquidity creates a discount, while those who buy many cases take on the time and the risks, reaping the return.


Rhuan Caldeira (Junior at GN Poli)



In legal claims and court-ordered government debts (precatórios), the dilemma is always the same: accept certain money today, at a discount, or wait for almost certain money in the future. In these transactions, legal claims are amounts already recognized by a court ruling, and precatórios are payment orders against the federal government, states or municipalities after a final decision. Therefore, although the difference between certainty and near certainty is small in numbers, it is enormous in people's minds. This is where Daniel Kahneman, Nobel laureate in Economics, comes in, showing that, in high-probability gains, we tend to be risk-averse and to prefer the peace of mind of the present over a larger gain later on. This preference, repeated across thousands of decisions, opens up room for strategies that reconcile economic value with psychology, one of the domains of special situations funds.


Special situations funds seek opportunities outside the normal flow of the markets, where there is complexity, illiquidity (difficulty converting the asset into cash quickly without losing value), time and legal risk (uncertainty linked to lawsuits, rulings and the interpretation of laws). In Brazil, this frequently appears in precatórios and litigious receivables (rights to receive amounts that are under dispute in court). The fund buys today, at a discount, a right to receive payment that depends on enforcement (the stage of the proceedings that turns the ruling into payment), on the payment queue and on possible contingencies (potential obstacles, such as appeals, attachments, disputed calculations or procedural changes). The targeted return includes the time until settlement (actual payment and final determination of the amount), plus a premium (additional compensation required for risk, term and complexity). In practice, these funds combine case origination, legal due diligence (a thorough legal review of documents, history and risks), financial analysis, structuring of collateral and portfolio management to dilute risks.


Source: Thinking, Fast and Slow (Daniel Kahneman):



In this sense, Prospect Theory organizes our behavior into a framework of gains and losses, and high and low probabilities. In high-probability gains, we are risk-averse and overvalue certainty relative to near certainty; in low-probability gains, we become more risk-seeking, like someone who buys a lottery ticket. In high-probability losses, we tend to take risks to avoid an almost certain loss; in low-probability losses, we seek protection.


Applying this to the topic, when the claim is almost certain, as in issued precatórios or rights with a final, unappealable ruling, the probability of receiving payment is high, but not total. Thus, the creditor (the party entitled to receive) sees an almost certain gain and, due to the certainty effect, prefers immediate liquidity. Present bias reinforces the preference for the now. Uncertainty about timing and the strain of following a long lawsuit increase discomfort and, combined with cash constraints, compress decision time. Bills to pay and urgent investments make the pressure grow. The result is often accepting a larger discount than would arise from a purely financial analysis, with ample cash and a long horizon.


On the other side is the buyer. The fund pays a discounted price today and takes on the bundle of risks: delays, enforcement, costs, regulatory changes and the payment queue all go into the model. The manager targets the spread between the purchase price and the expected value of the future payment, already net of costs and taxes. What is idiosyncratic risk (specific to one case) for the individual becomes diversifiable risk (which is reduced by combining several different cases) in the portfolio. The fund has patient capital, legal expertise and a due diligence process: it structures collateral, negotiates costs and improves selection through its own origination. In behavioral terms, the manager “arbitrages” (in market jargon, turns the seller's bias into gains in price and probability, exploiting an inefficiency) the seller's risk aversion. Where the individual overvalues the certainty of money now, the buyer sees the sum of many “almost certain” claims that, taken together, turn into returns. It is important to recognize that the discount does not come from bias alone: there are rational premiums for time, risk and illiquidity; psychology simply pushes the price even lower.


For example, consider a precatório of R$1,000,000, with payment expected in 24 months. The fund offers R$800,000 upfront. It estimates enforcement and legal costs of R$30,000 and assigns a 95% probability of payment within that period. The expected net future value is 0.95 × (1,000,000 − 30,000) = R$921,500. This implies an expected spread of R$121,500 over the R$800,000 outlay (about 15% over two years). If settlement occurs in 18 months, the annualized rate rises; if it slips to 36 months, it falls. This simple exercise illustrates how price, time, costs and probability, combined with illiquidity and enforcement, determine the return, and how the seller's discount finances the buyer's patience.


Consequently, at the intersection of economics and psychology, special situations funds carry out a behavioral arbitrage: with method and patience, they buy the “almost certain” claims that individuals prefer to turn into “certain” ones, at a discount. For the seller, it is worth recognizing when the desire for certainty and procedural fatigue are dictating the price. For the buyer, portfolio discipline, diligence and respect for regulatory and enforcement risks separate a legitimate premium from a gamble. Finally, the practical insight is that, in legal claims markets, the discount is influenced by the “price of peace of mind”: those who want certainty now pay to exit the process, and those who tolerate uncertainty and organize the risk turn this “relief premium” into returns.



bottom of page