top of page

Family Governance: Two Sides of the Same Coin

Writer: Grupo de Negócios da Escola Politécnica da USP
Grupo de Negócios da Escola Politécnica da USP
Oct 7, 2024
3 min read

While WEG shows that family continuity can be a strategic asset, Iguatemi faces distrust in this regard. Is family control good business for shareholders?


Lucas Scaramelli and Ana Rotenberg ( Seniors at the Group )



When analyzing a stock, many focus only on financial indicators, the macroeconomic scenario and the company's position in its sector. However, experienced investors know that governance and the decision-making process are equally crucial. Listed companies follow governance standards, but reality can be more complex, especially in the case of family businesses.


Even after going public, some of the largest companies on the Brazilian stock exchange, such as WEG (WEGE3) and Iguatemi (IGTI11), still have a strong family presence. These cases show two different forms of family participation in business decisions, resulting in different impacts on corporate governance.


WEG, founded in 1961, keeps 64.6% of its controlling stake with the founding families, which may initially raise distrust among minority investors. However, the company stands out for its long-term management and the continuity of its leaders, who have long careers within the organization itself. This reflects a solid culture focused on developing and retaining top-level executives, which ensures consistency in leadership.


WEG S.A. Shareholding Structure:



Unlike competitors such as Siemens and ABB, which change CEOs every 4 or 5 years, WEG bets on long-tenured leadership. The current CEO, Alberto Kuba, had already been with the company for more than 22 years before recently taking office, succeeding Harry Schmelzer, who led it for 16 years. This approach promotes a long-term strategic vision and stability, which has been an important differentiator for the company's sustainable growth.


As a result of this solid management and forward-looking vision, WEG maintains a high and consistent pace of growth, directly reflected in the appreciation of its shares in the market. Over the last six months, WEG's shares have risen 43%, reinforcing investor confidence in the company's strength, resilience and potential for continued growth.


In contrast, Iguatemi, which is undoubtedly a standout in Brazil's luxury shopping mall sector, has always been controlled by Grupo Jereissati, a family holding company. On the one hand, unlike WEG, most of its shares are traded on the market (free float); however, decision-making power is concentrated in the founding family, which holds 61.5% of the common shares, which carry voting rights at the shareholders' meeting.


Iguatemi S.A. Shareholding Structure:



Despite delivering competitive and resilient results during crises such as the pandemic and the rise of e-commerce, which threatened brick-and-mortar retail, distrust in family governance has been affecting the performance of its shares. IGTI 11 is trading at a discount in terms of its EV/EBITDA multiple, that is, the company's total value relative to its operating earnings generation is below its historical level (dashed line in the chart), showing that investors are less optimistic about the company's future.


Iguatemi S.A. Historical EV/EBITDA Multiple:




Two factors contribute to this: (i) saturation of the shopping mall market and (ii) distrust in the company's decision-making process. One example was the purchase of 16.6% of Shopping Rio Sul in partnership with the BBIG FII fund (33.3%), in a dispute with Allos, which was competing to buy the Rio de Janeiro asset.


The decision to invest in an overvalued asset, Rio Sul, at a cap rate (the ratio between operating income and the asset's sale value) of 7.7% — below the 8% paid in the past to increase its stake in Iguatemi JK, its most profitable mall and the one with the highest return on investment — instead of focusing efforts on increasing its stake in already consolidated and profitable assets, such as Iguatemi JK itself and Iguatemi São Paulo, which still offer great acquisition potential, resulted in lower returns for minority shareholders.


This highlighted a problem in the company's family governance: decisions that, although strategic in the long term for the controlling family, which paid an inflated price for Rio Sul to win the purchase competition against Allos, are often not aligned with the interests of minority investors.


As a result, Iguatemi's share price has fallen 4.5% since the date the acquisition was completed.


In short, while the family presence at WEG is seen as a strategic advantage, providing stability and a long-term vision, at Iguatemi, that same presence has generated distrust and below-expected results for minority shareholders.

bottom of page